孤独是什么:研究证据告诉我们什么
更新于 · 每条结论均引用其来源
由 AI 起草,结论已自动与引用来源核对
论文与期刊名称保留原文。
孤独是一个人现有关系与理想关系之间令人痛苦的落差。它在许多国家都很常见,并在前瞻性研究中与抑郁和死亡风险相关。心理项目、社会支持和部分数字形式的干预在试验中减轻了孤独感,但证据质量往往较低。
简要结论
孤独是一个人现有关系与理想关系之间令人痛苦的落差。它很常见,并与抑郁和早逝风险升高相关。研究显示,心理项目、社会支持和部分数字形式可能减轻孤独感,但效果通常较小,证据质量也往往较低。 [C2][C3][C4]
什么是孤独,以及它如何表现
孤独是一种主观体验:两个人可能拥有同样数量的社交联系,但只有一个人感到孤独。社会隔离则是客观上缺少联系和社会参与。两者并不完全相同,可能同时出现,也可能各自单独存在。 [C8][C9]
孤独通常通过简短的自我报告问卷测量。不同量表和判定阈值会产生不同估计。一项全球系统综述收集了113个国家或地区的数据,但不同年龄组的数据覆盖范围并不相同。 [C1][C1][C1]
青少年孤独感的合并患病率从9.2%到14.4%不等。成人数据只能针对欧洲地区进行合并。孤独也与健康问题有关,包括早逝风险和抑郁;这些结果显示的是关联,而非因果证明。 [C1][C1]
不同干预方式的研究结果
心理和认知方法
认知方法帮助人们重新审视对社交情境的解释和预期。痛苦耐受方法帮助应对社交时的不适,行为激活和社交技能训练则逐步增加联系机会。研究发现,团体干预、时间更长且频率更高的课程,以及认知或痛苦耐受方法具有更大效果。 [C2][C3][C7]
社会支持和团体活动
团体活动、同伴支持和辅导可以增加或重组社交联系。针对社区居住老年人的研究发现,社会支持干预能够减轻孤独感。在长期照护机构中,大多数干预效果较小;动物辅助疗法效果最大,但整体证据质量很低。 [C7][C7]
数字干预
包含团体或社交元素的数字心理项目、团体活动和机器人宠物显示出一定效果。单纯社交接触、自主个人活动和对话机器人效果有限。相关研究还存在偏倚风险、异质性和长期随访不足。 [C8][C4][C4]
年轻成人
针对年轻成人的六项研究显示抑郁平均水平有所下降,但孤独感的下降并未达到统计学显著。该年龄群体仍需要更多高质量研究。 [C5][C5]
局限性与不确定性
患病率估计取决于自我报告量表及其临界值。干预试验往往规模较小、异质性较高且随访较短。孤独与抑郁及死亡的关联主要来自观察性研究,因此不能排除反向因果和混杂因素。许多试验也没有与成熟的替代方案比较。 [C5][C6][C6]
何时考虑寻求专业支持
偶尔感到孤独是生活的一部分。如果这种感受持续数周,伴随持续低落、兴趣减退、睡眠或食欲变化,或导致回避过去重视的社交联系,就值得更加关注。搬家、丧亲或退休后,围绕共同目标开展的团体活动可能是自然的第一步。 [C7][C1]
如果孤独伴随抑郁情绪、焦虑或自伤想法,应向专业人士寻求帮助。医疗专业人员可以帮助区分孤独与抑郁发作,并讨论合适的支持方式。 [C4][C5][C2]
常见问题
孤独和社会隔离有什么区别?
社会隔离是客观上缺少联系;孤独是主观上觉得关系未达到自己的期待。两者都与早逝风险增加相关。 [C3][C7]
孤独会损害健康吗?
研究发现孤独与早逝及抑郁相关,但这些关联并不能证明孤独会导致疾病。 [C7][C9][C2]
孤独可以减轻吗?
心理项目、社会支持和部分数字干预在研究中减轻了孤独感。不过,多数效果较小,证据质量也往往较低。 [C3][C4]
数字工具有助于缓解孤独吗?
部分团体型数字项目和机器人宠物可能有帮助;单纯社交接触、自主个人活动和对话机器人效果有限。 [C5][C8][C4]
哪些干预对老年人最有效?
孤独通常通过自我报告量表测量,因此患病率取决于所用工具和临界值;成人估计值只能针对欧洲地区进行合并。干预试验往往规模较小,每种类型的研究数量有限,异质性较高且随访时间较短。最大效应来自长期照护机构,作者提醒应谨慎解读。孤独与抑郁及死亡的关联主要来自观察性研究,许多试验比较的是项目与不治疗,而非与成熟的替代方案比较。
结论与证据
- [C1]已确立
一项针对具有全国代表性的样本开展的系统综述与荟萃分析获得了113个国家或地区的患病率数据;青少年孤独感的合并患病率从东南亚的9.2%到东地中海地区的14.4%不等。
“Prevalence data were available for 113 countries or territories, according to official WHO nomenclature for regions, from 57 studies”
[S1] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“The pooled prevalence of loneliness for adolescents ranged from 9.2% (95% confidence interval 6.8% to 12.4%) in South-East Asia to 14.4% (12.2% to 17.1%) in the Eastern Mediterranean region”
[S1] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“Data were available for adolescents (12-17 years) in 77 countries or territories, young adults (18-29 years) in 30 countries, middle aged adults (30-59 years) in 32 countries, and older adults (≥60 years) in 40 countries”
[S1] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“the highest in eastern European countries (7.5%, 5.9% to 9.4% for young adults; 9.6%, 7.7% to 12.0% for middle aged adults; and 21.3%, 18.7% to 24.2% for older adults)”
[S1] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
局限: 成人数据只能针对欧洲地区进行荟萃分析;作者指出数据稀缺且方法学异质性较高。
- [C2]已确立
一项前瞻性研究荟萃分析发现,孤独感与早逝几率增加至1.26倍相关,社会隔离为1.29倍,独居为1.32倍;作者认为,这些关联的幅度与公认的死亡风险因素相当。
“social isolation odds ratio (OR) = 1.29, loneliness OR = 1.26, and living alone OR = 1.32, corresponding to an average of 29%, 26%, and 32% increased likelihood of mortality”
[S2] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“the influence of both objective and subjective social isolation on risk for mortality is comparable with well-established risk factors for mortality”
[S2] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
局限: 结果因参与者年龄而异;在较年轻的样本中,社会关系缺失对死亡的预测作用更强。
- [C3]视情况而定
一项纳入88项研究、共40,068人的荟萃分析发现,孤独感对抑郁具有中等程度的显著影响。
“it was decided to include 88 studies in the analysis. This study obtained a sampling group of 40,068 individuals”
[S3] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“loneliness had a moderately significant effect on depression”
[S3] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
局限: 纳入的研究大多为相关性研究,因此仅凭这项荟萃分析无法确定影响方向。
- [C4]视情况而定
一项纳入七十项随机临床试验、共8,259名65岁及以上参与者的系统综述与荟萃分析发现,大多数孤独干预的效果较小;长期照护机构中的动物辅助疗法效果最大,但研究异质性高,整体证据质量很低。
“Seventy studies were included in the systematic review (8259 participants)”
[S4] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Two authors reported being committee members of a Canadian guideline on loneliness and social isolation in older adults; no other disclosures were reported
“Peer-reviewed randomized clinical trials measuring loneliness and social isolation or support in adults aged 65 years or older”
[S4] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Two authors reported being committee members of a Canadian guideline on loneliness and social isolation in older adults; no other disclosures were reported
“Most interventions had a small effect size”
[S4] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Two authors reported being committee members of a Canadian guideline on loneliness and social isolation in older adults; no other disclosures were reported
“Animal therapy in long-term care, when accounting for studies with no active controls, had the largest effect size on loneliness reduction”
[S4] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Two authors reported being committee members of a Canadian guideline on loneliness and social isolation in older adults; no other disclosures were reported
局限: 每种干预类型的研究数量较少,限制了结论;整体证据质量很低。
- [C5]视情况而定
一项针对40项数字干预随机试验的荟萃分析发现,包含团体或社交元素的心理项目、团体活动和机器人宠物能够减轻孤独感;单纯社交接触、自主进行的个人活动和对话机器人效果有限。
“A total of 40 RCTs involving 6062 participants were included”
[S5] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declare no known competing financial interests or personal relationships
“along with group-based activities and robotic pets, were effective in reducing loneliness”
[S5] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declare no known competing financial interests or personal relationships
“In contrast, social contact interventions, self-guided individual activities, and conversational robots showed limited impact”
[S5] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declare no known competing financial interests or personal relationships
“Social media reduction interventions suggested potential benefits, though results were not statistically significant”
[S5] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The Authors declare no known competing financial interests or personal relationships
“The evidence base exhibited moderate to high risk of bias, heterogeneity, and limited long-term follow-up”
[S5] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The Authors declare no known competing financial interests or personal relationships
局限: 证据存在中至高偏倚风险、异质性以及长期随访不足。
- [C6]初步证据
一项针对年轻成人社会联结干预的荟萃分析纳入六项研究,发现抑郁总体平均水平有所下降,但孤独感的合并降幅在统计学上并不显著。
“Six studies were included; four in-person interventions with higher education students, one online intervention with higher education students, and one intervention for youth involved in street life”
[S6] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declare no competing interests
“The interventions were associated with an overall mean reduction in depression for young adults”
[S6] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declare no competing interests
“there was no overall statistically significant mean reduction in loneliness for young adults in pooled analyses”
[S6] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declare no competing interests
局限: 大多数研究在偏倚风险方面存在一些或中等程度的顾虑。
- [C7]初步证据
一项纳入三十五项随机试验、共5,291名老年人的荟萃分析发现,团体干预、时间更长且频率更高的课程,以及认知或痛苦耐受方法具有更大的效应量。
“Thirty-five RCTs from 31 published studies (total N = 5291 participants) met review criteria”
[S7] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“Meta-regression analysis found that distress tolerance interventions, group interventions, interventions with longer and more frequent sessions, and cognitive or acceptance of aging-focused interventions in older adults had larger effect sizes”
[S7] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
局限: 作者报告研究间异质性较高,认知干预和社会行为激活干预存在发表偏倚趋势。
- [C8]视情况而定
一项针对社区居住老年人的19项随机试验荟萃分析发现,社会支持干预能够有效减轻孤独感。
“Nineteen studies met inclusion criteria”
[S8] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declared no commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest
“Social support interventions effectively reduce loneliness among community-dwelling older adults”
[S8] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: The authors declared no commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest
局限: 合并试验存在较高异质性。
- [C9]已确立
实际社会隔离和主观感受到的孤独都与早逝风险增加相关;该荟萃分析未发现客观与主观社会隔离测量之间存在差异。
“Actual and perceived social isolation are both associated with increased risk for early mortality”
[S2] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
“We found no differences between measures of objective and subjective social isolation”
[S2] · 系统综述 / 荟萃分析 · 利益冲突: Not stated in abstract
来源
- [S1] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 35140066 · DOI 10.1136/bmj-2021-067068
- [S2] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 25910392 · DOI 10.1177/1745691614568352
- [S3] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 29792097 · DOI 10.1177/0020764018776349
- [S4] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 36251294 · DOI 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2022.36676
- [S5] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 40698012 · DOI 10.1016/j.invent.2025.100856
- [S6] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 39150513 · DOI 10.1007/s00127-024-02722-1
- [S7] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 40930084 · DOI 10.1111/nyas.70046
- [S8] 系统综述 / 荟萃分析. PMID 41573241 · DOI 10.3389/fragi.2025.1594513
更多心理学内容
仅供教育参考,不构成医疗建议。如果焦虑或情绪低落严重或持续存在,或者你有伤害自己的念头,请联系专业人士或当地紧急服务。