The short answer
Othership scores highest overall, for its large library, music-driven sessions and live classes — at $129.99 a year. Breathwrk is the affordable guided option: exercises, daily classes and programs for $49 a year, and free with some Peloton memberships. The Wim Hof Method app is the cheapest at $42.99 a year, but it teaches one method — choose it only if that method is what you want.
| | Breathwrk | Othership | Wim Hof Method app | |---|---|---|---| | Best at | Affordable guided routine | Music-driven sessions, live classes | The Wim Hof method + cold exposure | | Techniques | Box, 4-7-8, humming, long exhale and more | Mostly rhythmic, music-led | One method | | Annual price (US) | $49 | $129.99 | $42.99 | | Monthly price (US) | $9 | $17.99 | $5.99 | | Free content | Free tier | 5 rotating free sessions | Free basic version | | 3-year cost | ~$147 | ~$390 | ~$129 |
Choose Breathwrk if…
- you want an affordable guided routine with a free plan to start;
- you want short, structured daily sessions;
- you already pay for Peloton All-Access, Guide or App+ (Breathwrk is included).
Full details in our Breathwrk review.
Choose Othership if…
- music and production quality are what keep you coming back;
- live community classes matter to you;
- $129.99 a year is fine for that experience.
Full details in our Othership review.
Choose the Wim Hof Method app if…
- the Wim Hof method is your main practice;
- you want structured progression and cold-exposure guidance;
- you can practise safely (see below).
Full details in our Wim Hof Method app review.
Is Wim Hof breathing safe?
Wim Hof breathing is rapid, deep breathing followed by breath-holds. It can cause tingling, dizziness and, in some people, fainting. Never practise it in or near water, while driving, or standing where a fall could hurt you. Do it sitting or lying down. Talk to a doctor first if you are pregnant or have a heart condition, epilepsy or high blood pressure.
What does the research say?
Two breathing techniques have solid trial data. In a Stanford randomised trial, five minutes a day of cyclic sighing improved mood and lowered breathing rate more than mindfulness meditation (Balban 2023). In a Radboud University trial, people trained in the Wim Hof method showed a smaller inflammatory response to an injected bacterial toxin (Kox 2014) — the breathing, not the cold, appears to drive that effect. Apps themselves have not been tested head to head. For the honest picture on what breathing does to HRV, see what breathing and cold really do to your HRV.
Related comparisons
Breathwrk vs Othership, Breathwrk vs SOMA Breath, Wim Hof Method app vs SOMA Breath, or the full best breathwork apps of 2026.
Sources
- Balban MY et al. (2023). Brief structured respiration practices enhance mood and reduce physiological arousal. Cell Reports Medicine 4(1):100895. doi:10.1016/j.xcrm.2022.100895
- Kox M et al. (2014). Voluntary activation of the sympathetic nervous system and attenuation of the innate immune response in humans. PNAS 111(20):7379–7384. doi:10.1073/pnas.1322174111
- Breathwrk — official site (Pro pricing, Peloton membership; checked 2026-10-11), Breathwrk on the App Store (checked 2026-10-11), Othership on the App Store and Wim Hof Method on the App Store, checked 2026-10-03